Employees May Have Privacy Rights in their Personal Emails Sent on Company Computers
March 1, 2011 by Personal Privacies
Filed under Information privacy law
Employees May Have Privacy Rights in their Personal Emails Sent on Company Computers
Free Online Articles Directory
Why Submit Articles?
Top Authors
Top Articles
FAQ
ABAnswers
0 && $.browser.msie ) {
var ie_version = parseInt($.browser.version);
if(ie_version Login
Register
Hello
My Home
Sign Out
Email
Password
Remember me?
Lost Password?
Home Page > Business > Human Resources > Employees May Have Privacy Rights in their Personal Emails Sent on Company Computers
Employees May Have Privacy Rights in their Personal Emails Sent on Company Computers
Posted: Dec 04, 2009 |Comments: 0
| Views: 351 |
]]>
Most employees just accept the fact that their employer can access any content that is on a company computer, including employees’ personal emails and other personal information. But, is that the law? A growing number of courts are recognizing that employees have some expectation of privacy with respect to their personal content on company computers. Some recent decisions have held that employers do not own and cannot access their employees’ personal emails not even when those emails were sent on a company computer.
Marina Stengart v. Loving Care Agency, Inc. is a workplace privacy case that was decided on June 26, 2009. Marina Stengart worked as an Executive Director of Nursing at Loving Care Agency, Inc. Loving Care provided Stengart with a company computer and an email address to accomplish her work duties. Loving Care had an electronic communications policy which stated that emails, internet use and computer files are considered the company’s property and “are not to be considered private or personal to any individual employee.” The policy also stated that the company had “the right to review, audit, intercept, access, and disclose all matters on the company’s media systems and services at any time, with or without notice.”
Stengart used her company computer to email her attorneys about filing a discrimination lawsuit against Loving Care. But, Stengart did not use her company email address. She emailed her attorneys with her personal, password protected Yahoo email account while using her company computer. Stengart resigned from her employment and sued Loving Care for discrimination. Loving Care then searched Stengart’s company computer and, pursuant to its electronic communications policy, read the emails Stengart exchanged with her attorneys. Stengart angered by Loving Care’s reading of her personal emails, asked the Court to decide if Loving Care had the right under its electronic communications policy to read emails she sent to her attorneys through her personal email account on her company computer.
The Stengart Court rejected the notion that an employee’s personal emails become company property simply because the company owns the computer, claiming that a company computer in this setting is little more than a file cabinet: “Property rights are no less offended when an employer examines documents stored on a computer as when an employer rifles through a folder containing an employee’s private papers or reaches in and examines the contents of an employee’s pockets; indeed, even when a legitimate business purpose could support such a search, we can envision no valid precept of property law that would convert the employer’s interest in determining what is in those locations with a right to own the contents of the employee’s folder of private papers or the contents of his pocket.” The Court ruled against Loving Care, concluding that an employer cannot “transform all private communications into company property — merely because the company owned the computer used to make the private communications or used to access such private information during work hours.”
Marina Stengart asked the Court if her employer had the right to view her personal emails. Bonnie Van Alstyne took the workplace privacy notion a step further when she sued her former employer for accessing her personal emails. Bonnie Van Alstyne worked as a Vice President at Electronic Scriptorium Limited, a small data conversion company owned and operated by Edward Leonard. Van Alstyne had a company email account, but she occasionally used her personal AOL email account to conduct business. Van Alstyne’s employment was terminated and she filed a sexual harassment lawsuit against the company. During the discovery process, Van Alstyne learned that Edward Leonard accessed her personal email account both during and after her employment. Leonard produced 258 emails he had printed from Van Alstyne’s personal email account.
Van Alstyne filed a separate lawsuit against Leonard, Bonnie Van Alstyne v. Electronic Scriptorium Limited, et al. Her lawsuit alleged that Leonard violated the Stored Communications Act when he accessed her personal email account and viewed her emails. The Stored Communications Act creates criminal and civil liability for any individual who “intentionally accesses without authorization a facility through which an electronic communication service is provided” or “intentionally exceeds an authorization to access that facility” and “obtains, alters, or prevents authorized access to a wire or electronic communication while it is in electronic storage in such system.” In other words, the Stored Communication Act prohibits an individual from, among other things, intentionally accessing other people’s stored emails, voicemails, text messages, etc. without permission. A jury found that Leonard violated the Stored Communications Act and awarded Van Alstyne $250,000 in compensatory and punitive damages and more than $136,000 in attorneys fees and costs.
The law is changing. Courts are recognizing that employees have a right to privacy in their personal emails even when those emails are sent on company computers and even when company policy says otherwise. But, both Marina Stengart’s and Bonnie Van Alstyne’s employers read their personal emails which gave their employers valuable defensive information and severely prejudiced Stengart and Van Alstyne in their pending lawsuits. A lawsuit cannot unring that bell. And, Stengart and Van Alstyne were forced into lengthy, costly legal battles to enforce their privacy rights. It is encouraging that courts are recognizing employee privacy rights and giving employees remedies when those rights are violated. However, the best course of action is to keep your personal email and your company computer separate thereby eliminating any possibility that your employer will view your personal emails.
Retrieved from “http://www.articlesbase.com/human-resources-articles/employees-may-have-privacy-rights-in-their-personal-emails-sent-on-company-computers-1541864.html”
(ArticlesBase SC #1541864)
Need more traffic? No problem. Publish with us and see why everyone’s talking about Articlesbase.com
Liked this article? Click here to publish it on your website or blog, it’s free and easy!
Shalanda Ballard -
About the Author:
Shalanda Ballard is an employment defense attorney who has practiced in all facets of employment litigation. Ms. Ballard was named in the National Register’s Who’s Who and in Law & Politics Magazine as a Rising Star. She has spoken at continuing legal education conferences and employment law seminars. Ms. Ballard also writes an Employee Rights Blog.
]]>
Questions and Answers
Ask our experts your Human Resources related questions here…
200 Characters left
I’m working with a mlm company, which sells-computer courses, how can i do it more faster when i have no downline???
I would like some info on your digital resale rights pro for selling to my company, thanks Foster Oliver do you have a contact number for me either phone or via email
Is reading your childs’ email an invasion of privacy? My daughter got into a lot of trouble last yr when I gave her too much freedom. I now monitor her emails silently, and my sister says I am wrong
Rate this Article
vote(s)
0 vote(s)
Feedback
RSS
Print
Email
Re-Publish
Article Tags:
privacy, employees, workplace, personal emails, stengart, van alstyne, stored communications act, company computer, human resources, shalanda ballard, employee rights
Latest Human Resources Articles
More from Shalanda Ballard
Battlefield: Bad Company: Mercenary Gold
Kristin Holt is here to show you how to collect all the mercenary gold you can get your hands on in ‘Battlefield: Bad Company’. (01:53)
Battlefield: Bad Company – More Gold
Kristin Holt is here to show you where to find some more of that lovely yellow rock in Battlefield: Bad Company for the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3. (02:13)
How to Change your BlackBerry Email Signature
Want to change your BlackBerry email signature from ‘Sent from my BlackBerry® wireless device’ to your own personalized signature? Well follow our tutorial guide and within minutes you’ll be sending emails as if you were on a PC. (01:54)
How to Find All Email from or to a Certain Person in Gmail
If you’re anything like us, you get hundreds of e-mails a day. Updates from friends and family, work-related messages, updates from social networks, newsletters, flyers and more. Using the powerful search features of Gmail, it’s easy to find all messages from or to a particular person. Here’s how. (00:56)
Managing Multiple Email Signatures with TextExpander
Email signatures are great. They’re a handy way of personalizing and branding your email… sort of like a digital business card. However, email signatures are not one size fits all. Wouldn’t it be nice to have multiple email signatures you could access with a few keystrokes? One signature for business, one for family, one for friends and so on? With TextExpander it’s easy to manage multiple email signatures. (03:19)
Overview of Drug and Alcohol Screening
Employers make use of drug and alcohol screening to ensure that its employees and workplace remain safe and free of drugs. By drug testing, an organization can ensure that they do not hire people who abuse drugs. This also makes existing employees think twice about using illegal substances. In addition, testing is done to meet the terms of state and federal laws. This proves to consumers and the general public that employees are working in a safe environment.
By:
Pre-employ.com, Inc.l
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Feb 28, 2011
How Long Can I Wait to Complete the I-9?
As added protection to your business, the government requires that you as the employer must have every employee hired fill out the I-9 form. This form from the IRS has been in practice since November 6, 1896 and is simply insurance that you have checked that your employee has the documents and ability to work legally in the United States. Regardless of current immigration status, all workers including U.S. citizens, permanent residents, and temporary foreign citizens are required to provide docu
By:
I-9Compliance.coml
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Feb 28, 2011
How to Handle Employment Discrimination Allegations
Advice for properly handling employment discrimination allegations. Handling discrimination complaints properly and timely helps companies maintain their reputations as fair, ethical employers. Corporations need to follow the laws and work to rid their companies of discrimination.
By:
i-Sight Softwarel
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Feb 28, 2011
A Busy Year For Human Resources: EEOC Claims Hit Record Levels
Findings from a recent report from the EEOC demonstrate that employers need to brush up on laws, revamp compliance programs, investigate employee complaints and train employees on various types of misconduct.
By:
i-Sight Softwarel
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Feb 28, 2011
Choosing the Right Investigator For a Successful Workplace Investigation
Improve workplace investigations by choosing the right investigator for each case. Examine investigator skill set, level of expertise, severity of the case being investigated and the investigators relationship with anyone involved in the incident before you begin. These considerations will lead to the selection of the best investigator for the investigation.
By:
i-Sight Softwarel
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Feb 28, 2011
Web 2.0 is an often mentioned term nowadays and it has created such uproar throughout the human resource industry. Web 2.0 is the catchy name for the generation of web-based applications that encourage and emphasize interactivity and human collaboration through their platforms such as Facebook, Twitter and other networking sites.
By:
Kathryn Dawsonl
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Feb 28, 2011
A Simple Guide to Choosing the Right HR Outsourcing Company
Many companies have seen the value of outsourcing HR needs as a powerful tool to gain leverage in today’s competitive marketplace. Yet, it can only be as powerful as companies claim it to be if it actually produces the results beyond expectations.
By:
Kathryn Dawsonl
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Feb 28, 2011
Teambuilding and the Comfort Zone Connection
For many of us, we will spend our entire lives within the comfort zone. Fear keeps us in the boundaries where it is safe. Safe emotionally, physically, spiritually, socially… Adventure-based teambuilding offers the perfect platform for facilitating change, pushing the boundaries of the comfort zone and gaining revelation of the strength and power within YOU.
By:
Lauraleel
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Feb 27, 2011
The NLRA Provides Significant Rights and Protections to Nonunion Employees
Employees do not need to be union members to be protected by the National Labor Relations Act. The NLRA is generally perceived as protecting just union employees, but the Act really protects and gives rights to both union and nonunion employees. The NLRA gives every employee the right to engage in activities for the mutual aid and protection of employees, including activities that impact the terms and conditions of employment.
By:
Shalanda Ballardl
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Dec 11, 2009
lViews: 229
New Law Protects Employee’s Genetic Information
The employment provisions of the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) will take effect on November 21, 2009. GINA is groundbreaking legislation that addresses employees’ fear that their genetic information will result in adverse employment actions. The law prohibits (1) the use of genetic information in making employment decisions, (2) the acquisition of an employee’s genetic information, and (3) retaliation.
By:
Shalanda Ballardl
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Dec 04, 2009
Is Unconscious Bias Negatively Affecting Your Employment?
Thirty percent of Caucasians admit that they have a racial bias toward African-Americans. But, are those numbers accurate? Social scientists studying “unconscious bias” say that number is low. In fact, some studies have found that 88 percent of Caucasians have a pro-Caucasian or anti-African American unconscious bias. This article discusses how the theory of unconscious bias is beginning to be used in employment litigation.
By:
Shalanda Ballardl
Business>
Human Resourcesl
Nov 06, 2009
lViews: 367
Your Words Will Be Used Against You In A Lawsuit
The biggest mistake employees make is to talk about their claim when they are in an employment dispute with their employer. Many employees take a losing stand against their employers because they make statements that undermine their potential claim. Trevor Keezer, the Home Depot employee who was fired for wearing a “One Nation under God, indivisible” button, illustrates this point.
By:
Shalanda Ballardl
Lawl
Oct 30, 2009
lViews: 148
Ledbetter Fair Pay Act Breathes New Life Into Pay Discrimination Claims
This article discusses the Ledbetter Fair Pay Act which removed several barriers that prevented successful pay discrimination claims. The Ledbetter Fair Pay Act provides more opportunities to sue for pay discrimination. The Act also revived many previously time-barred pay discrimination claims.
By:
Shalanda Ballardl
Marketing>
Press Releasesl
Oct 16, 2009
How to Survive the New Terror at Work: The Workplace Bully
Bullying is becoming more prevalent in the workplace, especially in these difficult and uncertain economic times. Workplace bullying is aggressive or unreasonable behavior designed to negatively impact or destroy a coworker. Workplace bullying is designed to destroy you, your work, and your reputation. This article discusses practical advice on how to deal with a workplace bully.
By:
Shalanda Ballardl
Businessl
Oct 14, 2009
lViews: 432
Social Networking Can Get You Fired
Employees’ social networking activities are increasingly becoming the basis for discipline and termination. Those numbers will probably escalate in the future. Be careful when you are networking on Facebook, MySpace, LinkedIn, and Twitter because your social networking activities can result in discipline, up to and including your termination
By:
Shalanda Ballardl
Lawl
Oct 10, 2009
lViews: 147
A Workplace Romance Is Not Career Ending
Workplace romances have become the hot topic since David Letterman’s recent announcement that someone attempted to disclose his affairs with women working on his show. Workplace romances are fairly commonplace. You should know that a workplace romance can cause problems for you, your partner, and your company.
By:
Shalanda Ballardl
Lawl
Oct 10, 2009
lViews: 362
Add new Comment
Your Name: *
Your Email:
Comment Body: *
Verification code:*
* Required fields
Submit
Your Articles Here
It’s Free and easy
Sign Up Today
Author Navigation
My Home
Publish Article
View/Edit Articles
View/Edit Q&A
Edit your Account
Manage Authors
Statistics Page
Personal RSS Builder
My Home
Edit your Account
Update Profile
View/Edit Q&A
Publish Article
Author Box
Shalanda Ballard has 9 articles online
Articles Categories
All Categories
Advertising
Arts & Entertainment
Automotive
Beauty
Business
Careers
Computers
Education
Finance
Food and Beverage
Health
Hobbies
Home and Family
Home Improvement
Internet
Law
Marketing
News and Society
Relationships
Self Improvement
Shopping
Spirituality
Sports and Fitness
Technology
Travel
Writing
Agriculture
Ask an Expert
Business Ideas
Business Opportunities
Corporate
Customer Service
Entrepreneurship
Ethics
Franchise
Fundraising
Home Business
Human Resources
Industrial
International Business
Leadership
Management
Negotiation
Networking
Non Profit Organizations
Online Business
Organizational
Outsourcing
Presentation
Project Management
Public Company
Public Relations
Sales
Six Sigma
Small Business
Strategic Planning
Team Building
Training
]]>
Need Help?
Contact Us
FAQ
Submit Articles
Editorial Guidelines
Blog
Site Links
Recent Articles
Top Authors
Top Articles
Find Articles
Site Map
Mobile Version
Webmasters
RSS Builder
RSS
Link to Us
Business Info
Advertising
Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2011 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved.
Shalanda Ballard is an employment defense attorney who has practiced in all facets of employment litigation. Ms. Ballard was named in the National Register’s Who’s Who and in Law & Politics Magazine as a Rising Star. She has spoken at continuing legal education conferences and employment law seminars. Ms. Ballard also writes an Employee Rights Blog.
